A permit to work system is a formal, written process for controlling high-risk work: it defines what work is authorised, where, by whom, for how long, and which hazards have been isolated or controlled before anyone starts. During commissioning, the permit regime has to change as systems move from construction control to commissioning control and finally to operations. The hardest part is not writing the permit form. It is making sure everyone on site knows, for every system on every day, who owns the permit authority and which isolations are protecting whom.
This guide covers why permit regimes shift during commissioning, the common permit types, isolation management, and how to divide responsibilities when construction and commissioning are working side by side. It is general guidance for a UK audience. Your site's permit procedure, your client's requirements and your competent person take precedence, and the HSE publishes guidance on permit-to-work systems that you should read alongside your own procedures.
Why the permit regime changes during commissioning
During construction, most of the site is dead. Pipework is empty, cables are unterminated, and the main hazards are the familiar construction ones: work at height, lifting, hot work, excavation and confined spaces. The construction contractor usually runs the site permit system, and it is organised by area.
Commissioning changes the hazard profile one system at a time. The moment a switchboard is energised, a line is pressurised, or a vessel is filled with process fluid, that system can hurt people who are still working on it or next to it. A contractor finishing insulation on a line that was pressure-tested yesterday is now working on live plant, whether or not anyone told them.
That is why commissioning is organised by system rather than by area (see systemisation in commissioning), and why the permit regime has to follow the same system boundaries. Area-based permits alone cannot tell you that one pipe in a rack is live and the one beside it is not.
The three control phases
Most projects recognise three broad phases of control for each system. Names and exact boundaries vary by company and contract, so treat this as a pattern rather than a standard.
| Phase | Who typically holds permit authority | Energy state | Typical trigger to move on |
|---|---|---|---|
| Construction control | Construction contractor | Dead, not connected to any energy source | Mechanical completion and formal transfer to commissioning |
| Commissioning control | Commissioning team (often under the owner's or EPC's permit system) | Being energised, pressurised or run, system by system | Ready for start-up and handover to operations |
| Operations control | Owner / operator | Live, in service | Handover certificate accepted |
The transfer from one phase to the next is often tied to the certificate chain. The mechanical completion certificate is a common point at which permit authority for a system passes from construction to commissioning, and the commissioning certificate sequence usually marks the later transfer to operations. Whatever your project calls them, the key principle is the same: a transfer of care, custody and control should also be an explicit transfer of permit authority.
Common permit types on a commissioning site
Permit categories differ between organisations, but most permit to work systems on industrial projects include some version of the following.
- Hot work permit for welding, grinding, cutting and other ignition sources, especially near systems that may now contain flammable material.
- Cold work permit for general mechanical work on plant that does not involve ignition sources but still needs hazards controlled.
- Electrical permit (often called a permit for work or sanction for test, depending on the electrical safety rules in use) for work on or near electrical systems that are, or could become, energised.
- Confined space entry permit for vessels, tanks, pits and similar spaces, typically supported by gas testing and a rescue plan.
- Line or equipment breaking permit for opening systems that have held pressure or process fluid.
- Excavation or ground disturbance permit where buried services may now be live.
- Isolation certificate, which is not always a permit in its own right but is cross-referenced by permits that depend on an isolation being in place.
Many sites also use a sanction to test or similar document that allows commissioning to apply energy to equipment in a controlled way, for example to run a motor, while other permits on that equipment are suspended.
Isolation management: the part that goes wrong
Isolation management is the core of permit safety during commissioning. A permit authorises work; an isolation makes it safe. When construction and commissioning overlap, isolations become the most common place for confusion.
Why isolations get complicated at this stage
- Isolation points may not be finally installed, labelled or tagged when the first systems are energised.
- Temporary supplies, temporary pipework and temporary blinds are still in place and may not appear on any drawing.
- One isolation can protect several permits across different contractors, and removing it for a commissioning test can expose all of them.
- Drawings are still being marked up, so the isolation scheme may be based on a revision that no longer matches the plant.
A practical isolation process
The sequence below is a common pattern. Your site's electrical safety rules and mechanical isolation procedure will set the actual requirements.
- Plan the isolation against current, marked-up drawings. Identify every energy source: electrical, pressure, stored energy, gravity, process fluids and temporary supplies.
- Record the isolation scheme on an isolation certificate with each isolation point, method (lock, blind, spade, valve position, removed link) and verification step.
- Apply and secure the isolations, with locks and tags recorded against the certificate.
- Prove dead or prove zero energy before work starts, using the method your procedures specify.
- Cross-reference every dependent permit to the isolation certificate so nobody can remove the isolation without seeing what depends on it.
- Control any de-isolation for testing through a documented process that suspends or cancels the dependent permits first.
- Remove isolations only when all dependent permits are closed and the area has been handed back.
Lock-out tag-out practice sits underneath this process. If your team needs to write or refresh its LOTO procedures, WorkProcedures already covers that ground in depth, so we will not repeat it here.
Responsibilities when construction and commissioning overlap
Almost every project has a period where a system is under commissioning control while construction is still finishing punch items, insulation, painting or scaffold removal on or near it. This is where most permit disputes arise.
Agree a single permit authority per system
At any moment, each system (or subsystem) should have one permit-issuing authority. If construction needs to work on a system that commissioning now controls, the construction team applies for a permit through the commissioning authority, not through its own permit office. This sounds obvious, but many near misses come from two permit systems running in parallel with nobody sure which one applies.
Make boundaries visible on site
- Mark up the system boundary drawings showing which systems are under which control, and post them where permits are issued.
- Use physical signs, barriers or coloured tags on equipment that has transferred to commissioning.
- Update the boundary display at the same time the transfer certificate is signed, not a week later.
Define the roles
Terminology varies, but most permit to work systems separate these roles:
| Role | Responsibility |
|---|---|
| Issuing authority | Authorises the permit, confirms hazards are controlled and isolations are in place |
| Area or system authority | Confirms the work does not conflict with other activities or energised plant in that system |
| Performing authority / permit holder | Leads the work party, briefs the team and works within the permit conditions |
| Isolating authority | Applies, verifies and removes isolations |
| Competent person / specialist | Gas testing, electrical switching or other specialist checks required by the permit |
During the overlap, it is common for the issuing authority to come from commissioning while the performing authority comes from construction. Both need to understand the other's scope.
Handle punch work on transferred systems carefully
Outstanding punch items on a system that has already moved to commissioning control are a classic risk. The fitter who clears a Category B item may not realise the system was pressurised overnight. Tie punch close-out to the permit system: before a punch item is released to construction, check whether the system is under commissioning control and, if so, route the work through a commissioning-issued permit. Our guide to running a system walkdown covers how punch items are captured in the first place.
Common failure modes
Most permit problems during commissioning fall into a few recognisable patterns.
- Two permit offices, one plant. Construction and commissioning both issue permits for the same system because the transfer was not communicated.
- Isolations removed for testing without suspending permits. A commissioning engineer de-isolates to run a motor while a mechanical permit is still open.
- Temporary systems forgotten. Temporary power or temporary pressure connections are left live after the permanent system is isolated.
- Permits outliving their scope. A permit for "general work on system 21" stays open for weeks while the energy state of that system changes daily.
- Handover without permit reconciliation. Operations accepts a system with open permits or isolations it did not know about.
A simple safeguard is a permit and isolation reconciliation at each handover point: list every open permit and isolation on the system and either close it or formally transfer it to the receiving authority.
Permit to work checklist at system handover
Use this as a starting point when a system moves from construction to commissioning, or from commissioning to operations. Adapt it to your own procedures.
- All open permits on the system listed and either closed or formally transferred
- All isolations listed, verified against the current drawings and either removed or transferred
- Temporary supplies, temporary pipework and temporary blinds identified and recorded
- Boundary drawings and site signage updated to show the new controlling authority
- Receiving team briefed on the system's energy state and any remaining hazards
- Outstanding punch items reviewed for work that will need a permit under the new regime
- Permit authority change recorded against the transfer certificate
Managing permits in HSE-Track and Accord
HSE-Track supports risk assessment and permit-to-work documentation alongside incident, near-miss and hazard reporting, with offline mobile capture, photos and a full audit trail. That means near misses involving permits or isolations can be reported on the spot from site.
Accord includes a Permit to Work module that tracks active, pending and closed permits, integrated with scheduling and work packages. Because Accord also holds the system hierarchy and the certificate dependency chain, the team can see permit status in the same place as the system's completion and handover status.
Frequently asked questions
Who controls the permit to work system during commissioning?
It depends on the contract and the project's permit procedure. A common arrangement is that the construction contractor controls permits until a system is mechanically complete, the commissioning team (often under the owner's or EPC's system) takes over for that system, and operations takes over at handover. The important thing is that each system has one permit authority at any time.
What is the difference between a permit to work and an isolation certificate?
A permit to work authorises a specific task under specific conditions. An isolation certificate records how a system has been made safe, listing each isolation point and how it was verified. Permits usually reference the isolation certificate they depend on, so the isolation cannot be removed while the permit is open.
Can construction work continue on a system after it is handed to commissioning?
Yes, and it usually does, for punch items, insulation, painting and scaffold removal. The work should be carried out under a permit issued by the commissioning authority for that system, because the system may be energised or pressurised in ways the construction team is not aware of.
What is a sanction to test?
A sanction to test (the name varies between organisations) is a document that allows equipment to be energised or operated for testing while other work permits on it are suspended. It lets commissioning run a test without leaving open permits that assume the equipment is isolated. Check your own electrical safety rules for how this is handled on your site.
Is a permit to work system a legal requirement in the UK?
UK health and safety law requires risks to be assessed and controlled, and permit to work systems are a widely used way of doing that for high-risk activities. Whether a formal permit system is required for a particular task depends on the risk and the activity, so check the HSE's guidance and take advice from your competent person.
